Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Saturday 22nd November 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

KNOWLEDGE ISN'T KEY FOR MINISTERS OF SPIN

Story Image


IGNORANT: Byrne only wants civil servants to tell him part of what he should know

Wednesday November 19,2008

By Ann Widdecombe

IN a long list of instructions to civil servants, Liam Byrne, Gordon Brown’s new enforcer, asks them not to tell him what they think he should know but what they expect he might be asked.

This says everything there is to say about government today.

It is a candid and disturbing admission – reminiscent of Yes, Prime Minister – that what matters is PR, not real knowledge and governance.

The first duty of any official should be to give the minister the whole picture. When the minister has under- stood the situation as fully as possible then it is appropriate to worry about what others might ask.

If ministers aren’t fully briefed then no wonder the public has to manage with half-lies and inadequate information.

Years ago, when I was pensions minister in John Major’s government, I mentioned in a private conversation with a Labour spokesman that I felt it important that the public should know how the national insurance system worked because most thought it a fund which built up instead of the pay-as-you-go system it really is, with today’s takings paying today’s pensioners.

She retorted that it wasn’t at all necessary and that I only thought that because it backed up my argument that we could not restore the earnings link without raiding taxes.

SEARCH COLUMNISTS for:


I thought that an eccentricity until the weekend when I realised that appalling approach is now officially sanctioned.

Never mind the reality, what will John Humphrys ask me? This appears to be all that matters. Goodness knows how much of vital importance can be missed that way.

A civil servant has a duty to tell his minister what he thinks that minister ought to know and he cannot simply discard it because it is unlikely to be featured in questions.

Byrne would appear to be inviting his staff to neglect their prime function and he also appears to be saying that
ignorance is of no consequence as long as he sounds good when answering questions.

I doubt if any of those civil servants are even surprised because Government has been ruled by spin for a decade.

What you don’t know you can’t tell. Fine but nor can you make good judgments. I have never understood how the current economic mess was allowed to get so badly out of control.

Leverage is a posh word for borrowing and hedge fund is a posh phrase for a betting organisation.

Therefore a hedge fund operating on leverage is betting with borrowed money and they all appear to have been borrowing from each other. It was the economy of the madhouse.

Presumably some minister was so bothered about what he might be asked on Question Time that he didn’t do any asking of vital questions himself. What a way to run a country.

Yet now that way is the norm. All that civil servants are expected to concentrate on is where the trip wires might be, not on whether the device might explode anyway.

I can hope only that Liam Byrne’s permanent secretary (the senior civil servant in any department) said: “No, Minister.”


User Image

UTTER CONTEMPT FOR THE ELECTORATE

22.11.08, 5:48am

'Voter' is spot on regarding the truth about Labour's policies and intentions (and they may have even more calamitous initiatives on their agenda)
Unfortunately, knowledge of all this might very well scare the electorate into never voting again which would leave this collection of policy-wonk geeks, charlatans, liars, free loaders and out-and-out crooks in power for ever

• Posted by: RaferReport Comment

User Image

SOCIALISM CANNOT STAND THE TRUTH

20.11.08, 7:40am

Ann Widdecombe is right again. Socialism cannot stand the truth; if people knew the truth about it they would never vote. Imagine saying to people this: vote for us so that we can give perverse sex instruction to your children from the age of three; vote for us to scrap marriage; vote for us and we will have the highest taxes in the history of the country; vote for us and we will promise you a referendum on the EU and then not give you one; vote for us and we will increase immigration; vote for us and we will make political correctness more important to the police than solving crime; vote for us, we hold you in contempt.

• Posted by: voterReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Blog Author

Ann Widdecombe

To see all of the stories by this author, click the button below for a complete list.

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year